We have moved to a new Sailfish OS Forum. Please start new discussions there.

Revision history [back]

click to hide/show revision 1
initial version

posted 2015-10-03 10:57:55 +0200

Severe lack of feedback on carrier availability

Here is fresh usability test/field observation.

I was in the room of concrete building and I needed to make a call. OK, I took my Jolla out of the pocket and ran phone app. I found a contact and tap "call" control. Nothing happened. Once again and again... What, my Jolla freezes? Do not know how many time one could spend on that efforts, I was rescued but some passerby who gave me a hint.

As you may guess already the was no carrier in that room. But Jolla gave no clue about that. Moreover Jolla allowed me to try to perform action that was not available at the moment.

Please note: this not about fullscreen app or about statusbar. Such things should be more sophisticated than just permanent icon.

Suggestion:

  1. The mobile carrier unavailability should be indicated clearly at least when phone app is active.
  2. Controls of immediate actions (such as make a call) should be not active unless corresponding action is not possible. System must inform users clearly why they are unavailable.

Severe lack of feedback on carrier availability

Here is fresh usability test/field observation.

I was in the room of concrete building and I needed to make a call. OK, I took my Jolla out of the pocket and ran phone app. I found a contact and tap "call" control. Nothing happened. Once again and again... What, my Jolla freezes? Do not know how many time one could spend on that efforts, I was rescued but some passerby who gave me a hint.

As you may guess already the was no carrier in that room. But Jolla gave no clue about that.

image description

Moreover Jolla allowed me to try to perform action that was not available at the moment.

image description

Please note: this not about fullscreen app or about statusbar. Such things should be more sophisticated than just permanent icon.

Suggestion:

  1. The mobile carrier unavailability should be indicated clearly at least when phone app is active.
  2. Controls of immediate actions (such as make a call) should be not active unless corresponding action is not possible. System must inform users clearly why they are unavailable.

Severe lack of feedback on carrier availability

Here is fresh usability test/field observation.

I was in the room of concrete building and I needed to make a call. OK, I took my Jolla out of the pocket and ran phone app. I found a contact and tap "call" control. Nothing happened. Once again and again... What, my Jolla freezes? Do not know how many time one could spend on that efforts, I was rescued but some passerby who gave me a hint.

As you may guess already the was no carrier in that room. But Jolla gave no clue about that.

image descriptionimage description

Moreover Jolla allowed me to try to perform action that was not available at the moment.

image description

Please note: this not about fullscreen app or about statusbar. Such things should be more sophisticated than just permanent icon.

Suggestion:

  1. The mobile carrier unavailability should be indicated clearly at least when phone app is active.
  2. Controls of immediate actions (such as make a call) should be not active unless corresponding action is not possible. System must inform users clearly why they are unavailable.

Severe lack of feedback on carrier availability

Here is fresh usability test/field observation.

I was in the room of concrete building and I needed to make a call. OK, I took my Jolla out of the pocket and ran phone app. I found a contact and tap "call" control. Nothing happened. Once again and again... What, my Jolla freezes? Do not know how many time one could spend on that efforts, I was rescued but some passerby who gave me a hint.

As you may guess already the was no carrier in that room. But Jolla gave no clue about that.

image description

Moreover Jolla allowed me to try to perform action that was not available at the moment.

image description

Please note: this not about fullscreen app or about statusbar. Such things should be more sophisticated than just permanent icon.

Suggestion:

  1. The mobile carrier unavailability should be indicated clearly at least when phone app is active.
  2. Controls of immediate actions (such as make a call) should be not active unless corresponding action is not possible. System must inform users clearly why they are unavailable.

Update:

Tested feedback in Flight mode. All controls are active even in Flight mode. Tiny box on the top of the screen appears when tapping Call control. When tapping Send SMS the composing screen appears, you can compose message and even "send" it - it shows status "Sending..." ...and will show it forever without any clues of the reason of impossibility of sending.

So overall picture is nearly the same as when carrier is lost.