We have moved to a new Sailfish OS Forum. Please start new discussions there.

Revision history [back]

click to hide/show revision 1
initial version

posted 2015-11-11 16:26:38 +0200

Calendar reminder can be hard to notice

It seems to me that calendar reminder only reminds three times if the user doesn't respond to it in any way (let's say the device is silenced and not directly in view at the time(s) of the reminder. After that, there isn't even a blink of an LED to tell the user that there's something worth noticing. I've not tested fully if the count of three starts again if the user postpones the reminder or not, but still the reminder "gives up" way before the event start time. I'm not quite sure at this point if the reminder could be postponed more than trice, either.

There's also no LED blinking for a missed reminder, and I think that is just a bug, isn't a calendar event as important to note than a message? Maybe make it configurable if not everyone wants it, but please enable it somehow.

I don't know why I can't find a matching question for this since I think this is rather basic thing that should work better. It's also been like this already long time, if not from the start, and it still is the same in 2.0.0.10. I tend to have early reminders occasionally, and as the first reminder might be too early to actually get up and go, I'd need the reminder to keep telling me that soon I need to go.

Calendar reminder can be hard to notice

It seems to me that calendar reminder only reminds three times if the user doesn't respond to it in any way (let's say (could easily happen if the device is silenced and silenced, and/or there is enough background noise to block the sound, and the device is not directly in view at the time(s) of the reminder. the reminder kicks in). After that, three reminders, there isn't is not even a blink of an LED to tell the user that there's something worth noticing. I've not tested fully if the count of three starts again if the user postpones the reminder or not, but still the reminder "gives up" way before the event start time. I'm not quite sure at this point if the reminder could be postponed more than trice, thrice, either.

There's also As noted above, there's no LED blinking for a missed reminder, and while it might be considered as a topic of a feature request I think that is just a bug, isn't a calendar event just as important to note than a message? Maybe make it configurable if not everyone wants it, but please enable it somehow.

I don't know why I can't find a matching question for this since I think this is rather basic thing that should work better. It's also been like this already long time, if not from the start, and it still is the same in 2.0.0.10. I tend to have early reminders occasionally, and as the first reminder might be too early to actually get up and go, I'd need the reminder to keep telling me that soon I need to go.go (for example, when 1 hour before the event is too late but 2 hours before is still way too early). If something like https://together.jolla.com/question/98151/feature-request-nagging-calendar-event-reminder/ or https://together.jolla.com/question/95748/feature-request-having-multiple-reminder-on-a-calendar-event-needed/ were to be implemented to make reminders and/or postponing them more flexible, it might be that three reminders would be enough.

Edit 12.11.2015: added clarifications of the use cases + related questions

Calendar reminder can be hard to notice

It seems to me that calendar reminder only reminds three times if the user doesn't respond to it in any way (could easily happen if the device is silenced, and/or there is enough background noise to block the sound, and the device is not directly in view at the time(s) the reminder kicks in). After three reminders, there is currently not even a blink of an LED LED to tell the user that there's something worth noticing. I've not tested fully if the count of three starts again if the user postpones the reminder or not, but still the reminder "gives up" way before the event start time. I'm not quite sure at this point if the reminder could be postponed more than thrice, either.

As noted above, there's no LED blinking for a missed reminder, and while it might be considered as a topic of a feature request I think that is just a bug, isn't a calendar event just as important to note than a message? Maybe make it configurable if not everyone wants it, but please enable it somehow.

I don't know why I can't find a matching question for this since I think this is rather basic thing that should work better. It's also been like this already long time, if not from the start, and it still is the same in 2.0.0.10. I tend to have early reminders occasionally, and as the first reminder might be too early to actually get up and go, I'd need the reminder to keep telling me that soon I need to go (for example, when 1 hour before the event is too late but 2 hours before is still way too early). If something like https://together.jolla.com/question/98151/feature-request-nagging-calendar-event-reminder/ or https://together.jolla.com/question/95748/feature-request-having-multiple-reminder-on-a-calendar-event-needed/ were to be implemented to make reminders and/or postponing them more flexible, it might be that three reminders would be enough.enough (as well as in the case if there was a LED blink for missed events, see the link above).

Edit 12.11.2015: added clarifications of the use cases + related questions Edit 13.11.2015: linked to Holger's Q on the LED blink, making this only consider the reminder repetition

Calendar reminder can be hard to notice

It seems to me that calendar reminder only reminds three times if the user doesn't respond to it in any way (could easily happen if the device is silenced, and/or there is enough background noise to block the sound, and the device is not directly in view at the time(s) the reminder kicks in). After three reminders, there is currently not even a blink of an LED to tell the user that there's something worth noticing. I've not tested fully if the count of three starts again if the user postpones the reminder or not, but still the reminder "gives up" way before the event start time. I'm not quite sure at this point if the reminder could be postponed more than thrice, either.

I don't know why I can't find a matching question for this since I think this is rather basic thing that should work better. It's also been like this already long time, if not from the start, and it still is the same in 2.0.0.10. I tend to have early reminders occasionally, and as the first reminder might be too early to actually get up and go, I'd need the reminder to keep telling me that soon I need to go (for example, when 1 hour before the event is too late but 2 hours before is still way too early). If something like https://together.jolla.com/question/98151/feature-request-nagging-calendar-event-reminder/ or https://together.jolla.com/question/95748/feature-request-having-multiple-reminder-on-a-calendar-event-needed/ were to be implemented to make reminders and/or postponing them more flexible, it might be that three reminders would be enough (as well as in the case if there was a LED blink for missed events, see the link above).

Edit 12.11.2015: added clarifications of the use cases + related questions

Edit 13.11.2015: linked to Holger's Q on the LED blink, making this only consider the reminder repetition