We have moved to a new Sailfish OS Forum. Please start new discussions there.

Revision history [back]

click to hide/show revision 1
initial version

posted 2019-12-17 00:26:20 +0200

Have remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1: swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now: Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort. That means: no swipe gesture & minimal accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even [the changelog](https://together.jolla.com/question/217840/#217840-sailfishsilica-qt5 shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.

Have Having remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1:
swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now:
Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort. abort.
That means: no swipe gesture & minimal accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even [the changelog](https://together.jolla.com/question/217840/#217840-sailfishsilica-qt5 the changelog shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.

Having remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1:
swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now:
Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort.
That means: nono swipe swipe gesture & minimalminimal accessibility accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even the changelog shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.

Having remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1:
swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now:
Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort.
That means: no swipe gesture & minimal accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even the changelog shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.

Having remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1:
swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now:
Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort.
That means: no swipe gesture & minimal accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even the changelog shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.

Having remorses for your remorse timer redesign?

@jovirkku please pass this on to Martin or whomever is the responsible dev right now


The new design for remorse items is a disimprovement!

Before 3.2.1:
swipe away to finish action, tap to abort. easy, mnemonic gesture favoring the safe abort action via a quick tap anywhere on the remorse timer

Now:
Left 3 quarters of remorse item: confirm action, right quarter button like area to abort.
That means: no swipe gesture & minimal accessibility for canceling a remorse action

I'm always rooting for you guys and am trying to be objective.
But honestly have you lost any sense of good UX design?
I mean even the changelog shows that someone wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this change:

[sailfishsilica] Adapt remorse to yet another design.