[wiki] 100 paper cuts in SFOS 3
asked 2019-11-22 23:38:52 +0200
This post is a wiki. Anyone with karma >75 is welcome to improve it.
Similar to Ubuntu's 100 paper cut project, I propose to launch a similar project listing 100 bugs persistent in the latest SFOS release (3.2.0.12), which are annoying/damaging user experience while also being relatively minor to fix.
Not sure if similar ideas have been launched or proposed (and succeeded or failed), but the goal is to help Sailfish OS developers identify, in one wiki post, the most annoying minor bugs that, if fixed, can hugely improve the experience of using SFOS.
I propose the following rules :
- A minor bug that annoy/damage the user experience
- Only for SFOS core OS for starter (no Android compatibility bugs)
- Targets also Jolla's official apps (mail, calendar, etc.)
- No major features (new browser engine, QT version upgrade, etc.), these are not paper cuts
- Separate post or answer for each paper cut bug, and listing as a link in the main wiki post
- Unofficial patches are not considered as a fix. Users need not to hack their device to have a usable OS.
Please read through the entire list before adding items to avoid duplication
Please don't use this question as a dump for bug reports and feature requests. This is for paper cut bugs
The 100 paper cut bugs for SFOS 3:
Sound volume bar disappearingFixed in 3.2.1- XA2 call volume is low
- Opening email from notifications does not mark it as read
- Call volume is muted at both ends (post 1, post 2)
- Can't select a default calendar, also here
- Can't set the first day of week in calendar, and also here
- Email app UI
- The Settings app Apps and Accounts options dont fit with the rest. (Screenshot to explain what is wrong)
- DuckDuckGo as search engine Workarounds: one two
- Mark/Flag/Star emails (papercut?)
- Search by date in email (papercut?)
- Better search options in email (papercut?)
- Add "Mark as unread" to the pull-menu when reading an e-mail
- Show textual download state for system update downloads
- synchronize Twitter account from events view
- Adressbar in native browser does not disappear on some pages
Caller name is sometimes not shownThis issue seems to have been fixed in version 3.2.1.20- On call end sometimes the call lenght is missing in 3.2.0.12
Add an option to toggle a keyboard number row on default layoutsFeature request.- Sticky swipe when changing keyboard layouts. (might be a design decision but at least needs to be discussed)
Remove the X-icon on the remorse timer as it is confusing"Fixed" in 3.2.1.20 - Bring back old remorse timer functionality- Add an option to get back the brilliant "swipe to close" and "swipe to lock" behaviour that was standard in SFOS1
- Add an option to delete all history in Phone app
- Add an option to delete all SMSs in Messages app. (And another one)
- Select and delete multiple SMS messages
- Provide option to sort phone numbers of one contact or flag one number as default.
- Add remorse timer when deleting Clock Alarms
- Add remorse timer to any selected button in the Sailfish Utilities App
- Add GUI option for pkcon refresh to Sailfish Utilities
Show number being called, as well as name.See proposed rules aboveAttach photos direct to sms from within messagesSee proposed rules aboveMonthly calendar events on same day each month (e.g. 2nd tuesday of month)See proposed rules above- White in contact photos hides UI elements
- Email inbox selection bounces the page to the top
Global proxy settings having no effect in SFOS 3Bug, not paper-cutDoubletap zoom not working in Jolla browser (https://together.jolla.com/question/204856/bug-double-tap-zoom-does-not-work-in-sailfish-browser/)Bug, not paper-cutZooming out causes Jolla browser go blankBug, not paper-cut- Battery notifications hide the battery percentage indicator
- Flashlight doesn't always turn on
Add option to choose which synced account contacts are savedFeature request.email sync bug (under investigation): email auto-sync doesn't work as expected (see https://together.jolla.com/question/217890/email-sync-bug/)Bug, not a paper-cut- Calendar event reminder appears at original time and new time if reminder was moved
- Bluetooth gets stuck after disabling
- No quick-scroll (To Top/Bottom of page) available in Messages app
Browser sometimes crashes most other apps (out of memory condition?)See proposed rules above- master-password-for-browser (https://together.jolla.com/question/104491/master-password-for-browser/) - code already in browser app (Firefox based)
- Option to disable browser asking for password saving (a solution exist using about:config)
- Keyboard opening hides text to edit (e.g. editing post here, selecting text position, keyboard popping up and hiding text),
similar to Keyboard slips up and hides text Time app should remember the selected tab on closing and re-open on the same tab again.See proposed rules above- Top menu overrides pulley menu to 'close all'
Fix high power consumption on LTEBug, not paper-cutData on EXT4 formatted sd-cards, can be seen in gallery, but not shared with Android appsBug, not paper-cut- No calendar event reminders beyond 2 days
No search in MessagesFeature request.- Clearing individual notifications has no swipe option just. (inconsistent with everything else in SFOS)
- Top menu shortcuts for "Apps" and "Accounts" in Settings
- Swiping vertivaly nearly anywhere on the camera screen results in change from vid to pic mode and vice versa.
- Camera settings are tap and not swipe based. (resulting in far to reach motions)
- Hide photo deletion (and maybe info) in a pulley. Its quite easy to tap the trashcan and might result in accidental deletion of photos (also because of #21).
No way to import or export the SMS to or from SFOS to another non SFOS device, until you do a database dump.See proposed rules above. Also this is a feature request.- Add a bcc mail address permanent
- Show all emails in the unified inbox in email app regardless if read/unread
- Customize the Events view Twitter feed length
- Events view Twitter feed tweet length
- No feedback on "Force Stop" and others for Android apps in Settings / Apps
- Indistinguishable colours in tabs with lighter ambiances
- No way to remove "Tutorial" from launcher
- Move capture key selection of the camera app in the settings.
Not easily distinguishable text in the Clear Clipboard popupSeems to be fixed since 3.2.1- Power button menu shouldn't look just like the top menu
- Notes app: useless cover with clipped text that's scaled too big
- Glitchy animation transitioning in the home screen from close app screen
- People: Doesn't search Notes field (and lacks keys/tags,groups fields)
- Lock screen too similar to the home screen
Can't send SMS with "sender does not support replies", maybe due to formatting issueBug, but not a paper cut bug.- Messages: no longer possible to select text
- possibility to hide/delete recent contacts
- Undo (Cancel) option in Notes App
- No quick scroll buttons in native browser app
- Can't lock with a swipe (see here) (Revert UI regression)
- Can't close app consistency swiping down. Solution 1 is adding a configurable option here, solution 2 is revert the old code. This is a temporary solution (Revert UI regression)
- Create/add different calendars on device https://together.jolla.com/question/1563/createadd-different-calendars-on-device/
- Messages: default/accidental long press action is Delete
- Incoming email -> display not activated?
- Backup should handle 'no space left on device'
- USSD codes not working correctly
regression, not a paper-cutRegression AND paper-cut: "A minor bug that annoy/damage the user experience" - No call history for phone numbers not stored in contact database- even older: https://together.jolla.com/question/143264/bug-past-communication-events-not-shown-for-unsaved-phone-numbers/
Email client - possibility to mark emails as SpamFeature request, not a paper-cutWeek View - improve the calendar fragmentFeature request, not a paper-cutUSB tethering / Internet connection sharing doesn't work anymoreRegression, not a paper-cutMost of the world is actively blocked from buying SFOS: i.e. No android support, no keyboard enhancements, no updates etc.Not a paper cut bugBackup and restore failing to restore contacts.Not a paper cut bugNo bug tracker.Troll- Calendar view doesn't update on midnight
- One-liner messages have distracting strikethrough on XA2 Ultra
- Improve possibilities to (auto-)lock the device
- Dial keypad feedback lag (DTMF playback)
Please feel free to complete the list with more paper cut bugs (already reported and not fixed, or new ones as new posts/answers). Again: This is for papercut-bugs. See definition above.
The question is if jolla wan'ts to put the effort in fixing those without some of their customers demanding it. Which seems to be the case. :/
BTW when we gather 100 small bugs we can discuss it in a meeting if someone from jolla hasn't responded here regarding resolution.
ApB ( 2019-11-23 13:23:45 +0200 )editThis is a very good initiative, @ApB.
vattuvarg ( 2019-11-23 17:23:10 +0200 )editShouldn't we drop numbering the list? They're all equally annoying.
Tanghus ( 2019-11-23 17:42:38 +0200 )editWhat about this? https://together.jolla.com/question/171437/what-bugs-does-sailfish-x-have/
Yo ( 2019-11-23 17:44:54 +0200 )editRegarding "The Settings app Apps and Accounts options dont fit with the rest.". IMHO it's not a bug, it's by design, so a matter of taste. It would be better in a separate issue/question so people can vote for it.
Tanghus ( 2019-11-23 17:46:25 +0200 )edit